Open Source Party 2.0: Liberty, Democracy, Transparency!

As Egypt undergoes its revolution, I find myself thinking about a strategy, a pathway to political agency; to real power; to liberty, transparency and democratic inclusion for the multitudes in America (and, ultimately, everywhere).

In November 2007, I presented a proposal to start a political organization I called the Open Source Party here at 10 Zen Monkeys. The idea was to bring open source principles into the political realm.

It was around the time when the media started barraging us with presidential politics, and so I framed the proposal around the oncoming 2008 elections. Here's a bit of it:
The duopoly will have its way again in this year's election. Ralph Nader and whoever the Libertarians and Greens nominate as their candidates will drag their asses around the country, sometimes saying interesting and important things, sometimes not. Many of us will wish, once again, that there could be a dynamic discourse about the many real issues and problems that get ignored; and then we will vote (or not) for the one who has at least a fingernail grip on sanity, or for one of the sad and hopeless alterna-candidates.

Links were provided to a (now defunct) Ning network, and to The Point — a site that allows you to set a fundraising goal, and then forwards you the money if you reach it. We (other Zen Monkeys and myself) promised that we would do the legal paperwork, and officially establish the Open Source Party as a political organization, if we received $5,000 in donations.

As is often the case with these sorts of things on the internet, the proposal was met with a barrage of excited claims of support and loose chatter (and, of course, criticism), followed by pretty much zero commitment and zero donations. Still, some of the discourse was pretty interesting.

Jon Lebkowsky provided these:



Principles of Open Source Politics:

Openness

Many of us who are tech-focused have come to understand the power of open approaches and open architectures. Even technologies that aren't strictly "Open Source" benefit from Open APIs and exposure of operating code (kind of inherent with scripting languages like Perl and PHP). When we know how something works, we know how to work with it. And we know how to transform it to meet our needs.

Government should be as open and transparent as possible. There may be some rationales for closed doors, but few — for the most part, citizens should be able to clearly see how decisions are made. That's a key component of our political platform: we want to see the actual "source code" for the decisions that affect our lives.

Collaboration

Open Source projects are often highly collaborative and can involve many stakeholders, not just manager and coders. The Open Source Party sees this as a great way to do government. (I'm partial to charrette methodology, personally.)

Emergent Leadership

Effective action and decison-making requires leadership. In an Open Source form of politics, leaders emerge through merit -— by providing real leadership and direction, not by appointment, assignment, or election. Nobody made Linus Torvalds the lead for Linux, or Matt Mullenweg the lead for WordPress. They saw a need, created a project, and found an effective following who acknowledged their vision, expertise, and ability to manage and lead. Emergent leaders aren't handed authority. They earn it, and if they cease to be engaged or effective, they pass the baton to other leaders who emerge from within the group.

Extensible and Adaptable

Open Source projects and structures are agile and malleable. They can be adapted and extended as requirements changed. Governance should have this kind of flexibility, and our system of governance in the U.S. was actually built that way. We should ensure that bureaucracies and obsolete rule sets don't undermine that flexibility.



Lovely, right? But without any real substantive support, I concluded that the time wasn't right… and I let it slide.

Is the time right now?

A few months ago, a college student in Wisconsin asked me if I was interested in reviving the Open Source Party concept. I've been thinking about it ever since.

6 things that have happened since 2007 that make me think it may be time for Open Source Party:

1: Economy Nearly Collapses

With the crash of 2008, we had our noses rubbed in the plutocratic — and even kleptocratic — nature of the US and global economy ("too big to fail"). As explored in the film, Inside Job and elsewhere, major players in the finance, corporate and political worlds have consciously and systematically ripped everybody off and they've gotten away with it. We need some power to the people.

2: Technologically Enhanced Revolution in the Middle East

The revolution will be tweeted. There's a contagion for increased democracy, liberty and transparency. It could catch on here.

3: Wikileaks

The first intervention of radical transparency onto the global stage. It's a force that ultimately can't be stopped.

4: Pirate Parties in Europe

European hacker culture has created vital minority parties — "Pirate Parties" — largely based on open source cultural principles like liberalizing copyright laws and greater state transparency.

5: Netroots Elects a President (but gets the Same Old Shit)

Young "netroots" progressives put Barack Obama into the presidency by giving him an edge over Hillary Clinton in the primary. Once in office, Obama went into a huddle with the usual Democratic Party technocrats. The same old power centers — the giant corporations, the finance industry, the national security/drug war establishment ad infinitum — remain fully in charge, and in fact, they grow stronger. The Obama Administration represents the last gasp of "progressive" centrism — the strategy of trying to gently nudge these power centers toward being the engines of social responsibility. Now we have to learn how to do it ourselves.

6: Tea Party Populism

However wrongheaded and inchoate, the Tea Party is largely a populist uprising made up of people who don't want to be ruled by elites. More importantly for our purposes here, they've liberated the word "Party"! Hopefully, people will no longer automatically assume that an Open Source Party is another hopeless attempt at a "third party", organizing to run candidates in elections. Open Source Partiers could be a pressure group that operates outside the electoral process and/or operates as factions within extant political parties, depending upon the political leanings of the individuals or chapters.

What Is To Be Done?

To those of you interested in forming an Open Source Party, I suggest you (we) ditch my original script and start over from scratch. We should form a Wiki and create a new statement of purpose, charter, and plans.

I believe something like the Open Source Party is inevitable. Voluntary and open collaboration may well be the emergent socio-economics of the future and political activists will inevitably reflect that tendency. Eric S. Raymond's seminal essay, "The Cathedral and the Bazaar" may point the way forward. As Trevor Tomesh pointed out to me in an email, Raymond spoke about two contrasting models of software development:

"The Cathedral model, in which source code is available with each software release, but code developed between releases is restricted to an exclusive group of software developers.

"The Bazaar model, in which the code is developed over the Internet in view of the public.

Tomesh writes: "Let's just replace a few words here:

"The democratic republic model, in which policy is enforced with each bill passed, but policy development is restricted to an exclusive group of individuals (congress).

"The direct-democracy model, in which policy is developed by the public in view of the public.

"If we accept the latter rather than the former as the ideal way to go about democracy, we can reread Raymond's essay not only in terms of an optimal software development model, but as an optimal societal and governmental development model. Let us create a new model of democracy, using the bazaar as an example."

On the other hand, as Lebkowsky — who co-edited the book Extreme Democracy and has wrestled with questions about direct democracy for years — points out, the Cathedral and the Bazaar co-exist, and perhaps some mix of direct and representative democracy is the best way to go. Lebkowsky writes: "I used to say that we don't replace representative democracy, we swarm it."

Anyway, all this is open for discussion. And we're wide open to your views and visions as well. If you want to help form an Open Source Party, please contact Trevor Tomesh at trevor.tomesh@uwrf.edu.

Thanks to Jon Lebkowsky and Trevor Tomesh for contributing to this article.

Image courtesy of Political Realities

What Haley Stevens Said About Mike Rogers When Debating Abdul El-Sayed


Her opening statement?

"If Mike Rogers wins this race, all goes by the wayside."

Seriously — she said it, like, twelve seconds into her statement.

"Thank you to everyone tuning in tonight. As we know, the stakes of this race couldn't be higher. Costs continue to go up, our healthcare, voting rights, civil rights — it's all on the line, in addition to social security and Medicare. And if Mike Rogers wins this race, all goes by the wayside."



But shouldn't we be worried you'll just turn around and endorse him 97 days later? I mean, this was July 27th, about 14 weeks ago, as local station Fox 2 Detroit filmed two candidates facing off in the primary to be Michigan's Democratic Senate candidate. And "Look, Michigan deserves a senator who can win and who can deliver," Stevens said with conviction.

"I'm the only one on this stage who has a flipped a Republican seat! And I was named Michigan's most effective Democratic lawmaker in Congress. Because my only focus is you!"

It just seems like this weekend was all about Haley Stevens and her own image. Which makes it weird that her next attack line was "Abdul is running for celebrity." It could only be more ironic if she'd accused El-Sayed of helping Mike Rogers.

Oh wait, she's still talking...

"Republicans are propping up his campaign. And Mike Rogers, just the other day, said in a secret phone call, that he makes it easier to win! That he's the one he wants to run against."

There's more...

When the moderator asked about AIPAC's $46 million-plus donations, Haley Stevens deflected the question. ("Well, I don't think there's much difference between Super PACs going in for Abdul or Super PACs going in for me. We have a problem with campaign finance reform in this country.") But then the very next thing she said was...

"I have an A rating from End Citizens United! I have been endorsed by Defend the Vote! I have voted consistently, and I am going to stop Mike Rogers from getting anywhere close to the United States Senate! Which is why he doesn't want to run against me."

Screams of Irony

Every word screams with irony now. She hit Abdul El-Sayed about the fact he's written three books. ("We don't need a celebrity candidate... We need somebody who is committed! To six years of hard, unglamorous work, that's going to stand up to this junk that is wreaking havoc and causing chaos right before our very eyes.")

To be fair, El-Sayed's books were Medicare for All: A Citizen's Guide and Healing Politics: A Doctor's Journey into the Heart of Our Political Epidemic.


And Stevens herself has contributed to a book, a 2020 book about how committed millennials like Stevens will revolutionize American politics. The Ones We've Been Waiting For: How a New Generation of Leaders Will Transform America featured contributions from Pete Buttigieg, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and even Elise Stefanik — all up-and-coming millennial politicians. Maybe the lesson there is you have to be careful which politicians you're listening to...

After all, when Haley Stevens criticized El-Sayed for not releasing his full tax returns, she was the one said we needed to ask him what he's hiding? "What are Republicans going to uncover in the general election that they will use against him...?"

Stevens then went on to tell her audience that "I have been recognized as an effective Democratic lawmaker, who yes, governs in a clear, consistent way, on complex challenges."

She wraps up that speech by insisting that "That is what will do on Day One! And I have the receipts to prove it!"

El-Sayed's Ironic Criticism

There's also some irony in the remarks of Abdul El-Sayed. When El-was asked about his criticism of John Fetterman, El-Sayed insisted Fetterman "has done terrible things. He got elected on a set of values and is now completely throwing those values in the mud.

"And I do think it's important for any senator in Michigan to have a relationship with folks who are in the U.S. Senate, and if those folks are not actually acting in accordance with what they got elected on, I think it's important for all of us to have an honest opinion about what we're going to do..."

There was more fun to come. When the moderator asked Stevens why her opponent drew support from Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, and AOC, first Stevens rattled her own list of endorsements, then insisted she had a unique understanding of Michigan.

"So when Donald Trump and Mike Rogers go to lick the bootstraps of China, and start a trade war with Canada, screwing us over and selling us down the river? I will be standing up for us!"

She goes on to promise "to deliver for our youth, and equity and inclusion, that is so very important to our future. Jobs for everyone! Lower costs!

"And yeah, stop these abuses of power that are coming down from Trump and Rogers, who are treating it like the stock-trading floor!"

Virtually every question that came to Haley Stevens drew her impassioned promise to fight back again Mike Rogers. When asked if she was bothered that the UAW endorsed her opponent?

"I am so deeply proud to have a long-standing relationship with retirees and UAW members, and to have 17 labor endorsements in this race by a longshot.... Costs are killing us in our manufacturing center. The trade war with Canada has sold us out. There are a thousand Cleveland Cliffs workers, mostly in Downriver, that are out of work right now.

"You know, Mike Rogers wants to rubber-stamp all this! The stakes couldn't be higher. November is 50-50. He said on the leaked call he wants to run against Abdul..."


When questioned about her referring to "the fine people" at ICE, Stevens countered that she'd criticized their outrages, while El-Sayed was just looking to launch a future run for the Presidency. "That's not what this job is for me. That's not why I'm putting up my hand in this moment...

"This is about making sure that Mike Rogers doesn't get anywhere close to the seat! I'm the only one on this stage who has beat MAGA four times, and delivered repeatedly for this state and for our values, for our rights, and our freedoms..."

And believe it or not, the historically ironic debate all came down to one final question. And that question was...

"What makes you think you're the formidable candidate who can take on Mike Rogers?

El-Sayed: Poll after poll after poll has shown, despite what my colleague says, that I am the most competitive candidate to take on Mike Rogers...

But Haley Stevens just listed her endorsements. And then said that they all agree that "I will beat Mike Rogers, just like I have beat Republicans four times over!"

What We've Learned

It's a big day in America. Even Google created a special doodle.


And Monday morning saw a special guest essay in the New York Times. Its title? "Don't be a Haley Stevens."

Maybe it's proof that this whole spectacle can redeem itself, somehow leading by bad example. The essay looked at America's history — the Civil War, the Great Depression — seeing moments that required some faith in our community, and a recommitment to the idea of democracy itself. "For all of their shortcomings, the Democrats remain a mass political party in the American tradition, rather than the bizarre personality cult into which the Republican Party has devolved..."

Somehow the guest essay crystallized what Haley Stevens keeps missing. Whatever our differences, "We must first deal with the active menace at hand. History is a string of critical moments, which can never be regained or recreated just as they were. We cannot miss this one."

In short, "Don't Be a Haley Stevens". And the essay summarized the urgency of our challenge in six simple words.

"History doesn’t give us second chances."